Mobile app version of vmapp.org
Login or Join
Murphy569

: Adobe software undo selection Can Adobe Illustrator or Photoshop record selection history for undo? Selecting multiple things with "shift" key sometimes lost all selection when "shift" key failed

@Murphy569

Posted in: #AdobeIllustrator #AdobePhotoshop

Can Adobe Illustrator or Photoshop record selection history for undo?

Selecting multiple things with "shift" key sometimes lost all selection when "shift" key failed by mistake. So I need to work from start again.

10.05% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Login to follow query

More posts by @Murphy569

5 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

 

@Murray976

I do not understand what you are referring to.

In Photoshop Undo does indeed change the last selection. If you mistakenly deselect things, undo will reselect them. Basically, all Photoshop's undo does is take 1 step back in History. If that step backwards involves a selection.. it's undone/redone.



In Illustrator after creating a selection you can use the menu item Select > Save Selection and then recall that selection layer via Select > Load Selection. Because Illustrator is object-based not pixel-based, selections won't undo/redo the same way they do in Photoshop. And Illustrator has no "history".

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Harper654

A quick solution might be to use the select similar option. Particularly if the object's you're selecting are the same colour.

Edit. This is specifically for illustrator. My suggested work around in photoshop is to use the magic wand tool that would automatically select the colours, save that selection as a mask and then extract each colour from its various layers with a bit of cnp.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Reiling762

Photoshop already does this. Step Backward (Ctrl+Alt+Z) lets you undo multiple changes in the order they occurred. Step Forward (Ctrl+Shift+Z) lets you redo any changes you actually wanted.

I suspect that Illustrator has a similar feature.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Eichhorn212

Yes, save your selection often.

In Photoshop go to Select > Save Selection… and set it to replace the old selection each time you save (Replace Channel… see image). Selections are also saved as Channels in the Channels Panel behind Layers and Paths.

In AI you can save the selection, but I did not see an option to replace the previous selection, so you may need to rename it each time you save. Or like user75926 said, make a separate layer for your selction.

This way, if you lose your selection, you can hen Select > Load Selection… to get it back.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Frith110

In Illustrator, if your selection is that complex, try using the Layers panel, and/or saving the selection as you add & remove objects so if you lose the selection you can reload the last saved selection rather than start over.

In Photoshop, use QuickMask or even create a new alpha channel. Edits to quickmask/alpha appear in the undo history subject to Ctrl-Z.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Back to top | Use Dark Theme