Mobile app version of vmapp.org
Login or Join
Lengel546

: Can referrer-based web page content be SEO friendly? Basically, I am going to be using the page referrer to display different content on a given page. It won't be the entire page depending

@Lengel546

Posted in: #Content #Referrer #Seo

Basically, I am going to be using the page referrer to display different content on a given page. It won't be the entire page depending on the referrer, but little aspects like the way titles are phrased or the topic of a feed displayed in the sidebar.

For example, let's say I have a website about animals. Now let's say someone Googles "bears" and clicks through to my page, and because the page detects that the referrer is a Google search for bears it shows more bear content. However, that same page will also show more content about lions if the referring page is a Google search for "lions". These "two" pages are located at the same web address. Can this page grow in search rankings for both topics even though it will only show one of the two types of pages based on the referring page?

10.03% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Login to follow query

More posts by @Lengel546

3 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

 

@Nimeshi995

Well, I would like to tell you that Google gives credit to Niche content & niche pages. Becaue today's era Google work according to user search query. Like if user is looking for lions on search then Google will only find the exact information on the search, if you have the information about bears & lions on the same page then It will completely ignore your page & it will give preference to the exact match page who have the only Lions on the same page.

I hope you got an idea

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Heady270

The only way that Google knows your page is about bears is that you give it content about bears when it crawls the page. When Google crawls the page, you have to choose whether it is about bears or lions. Then Google ranks the page for the appropriate term. When Googlebot crawls, it doesn't send a referrer, so you can't make the decisions based on the referrer for the crawler.

If you have content about bears and other content about lions, it is best for SEO to put them on two different pages.

The other problem with using the referrer from Google to power your site is "not provided" keywords. Google doesn't send a referrer with keyword in it most of the time nowdays. For most searchers, you wouldn't know if they had searched for bears or lions.

I have code in one of my sites that tries to direct users to the correct page based on their search term. I'll put a notice like this up:


I see you searched for "lions" but this page is mostly about "bears". Click here to read about lions.


The site works this way because there were a bunch of cases where Google was ranking the wrong page. Google has since improved and usually ranks the correct page on my site nowdays, so I'm not very upset that the "not provided" makes it useless.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Ann8826881

It sounds like you are on dangerous grounds.

I assume that Googlebot will always get the same page since, according to your example, there is no search involved. But please do know that Google checks pages using domain names, IP addresses and agents other than Google's own to validate that a page is not cloaked.

What you are describing falls within the cloak category.

It is always bad practice to display different content to a user than a search engine and it is likely a bad idea to do what you are describing.

Do I think there is an SEO factor in all this? Yes. Penalty.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Back to top | Use Dark Theme