Mobile app version of vmapp.org
Login or Join
Angie530

: Do soft 404 errors on wiki sites caused by pages not yet created cause SEO problems? I host a couple of wiki based sites, so there is a lot of content at various stages of generation, and

@Angie530

Posted in: #Seo #Soft404 #WebCrawlers #Wiki

I host a couple of wiki based sites, so there is a lot of content at various stages of generation, and lots of links to pages that have yet to be created. Of course, these links are generating soft 404 "errors" when Googlebot crawls the site.

There was a good answer given in: How to fix soft 404 in an Ajax Driven website? The suggestion was to put a no-index command in the robots.txt for each of the not yet created pages.

However that sort of defeats the purpose of the flexibility inherent in the wiki format. The wiki shows the "missing" page links in red, so this is not a user experience problem, but rather, it is kind of the point of a wiki, to encourage further content growth.

So I guess the question is "does it matter?" How worried would you be about this if it was happening to you? I have never really had great rankings, and I'm wondering if this could be part of the problem?

10.01% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Login to follow query

More posts by @Angie530

1 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

 

@Berumen354

Soft HTTP 404s errors in search console are pages returning HTTP 200 Ok response codes in pages that Google consider with low value to the user. In this Google help forum about soft 404s they states the following:


Returning a success code, rather than 404/410 (not found) or 301
(moved), is a bad practice.


So to answer your question in short: Yes, soft 404 errors do cause SEO problems.

It is also evident that Google treats 404 and soft 404 http errors the same way and that Google will deindex those pages if they aren’t fixed quickly.

My Recommendation

A quick solution would be, you can create a example.com/useful-template with 90% of the content that will be reused, just change 50% title Like "Content for Water Supply coming up" and the last paragraph. Then with this template apply it to all the other pages in "development" and make sure that you add a canonical tag pointing to /useful-template like:

<link rel="canonical" href="http://example.com/useful-template">


Happy wiking ;)

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Back to top | Use Dark Theme