Mobile app version of vmapp.org
Login or Join
Merenda212

: Google indexes 301 source, with the destination content It seems like when you 301 a page A to page B, sometime google indexes page A, showing the url in the results, with the contents of

@Merenda212

Posted in: #GoogleSearch

It seems like when you 301 a page A to page B, sometime google indexes page A, showing the url in the results, with the contents of page B?

Google "site:http://tinyurl.com/" to see some examples

Is this by design or a bug?
How do I avoid it?

10.02% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Login to follow query

More posts by @Merenda212

2 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

 

@Rambettina238

When I actually Googled for site:http://tinyurl.com/, all the links on the first page were dead redirects to non-existing pages (HTTP status code 404).

Apparently, what's happening here is that TinyURL detects such 404 errors, and sends the user to their own notification page at find.searchassist.com instead (example).
They do this through a sequence of redirects, some of which are temporary; for the example above, I count three redirects:


HTML meta refresh (with delay 0) to tinyurl.com/errora.php?url=... HTTP 302 temporary redirect to goto.searchassist.com/find?p=... HTTP 307 temporary redirect to find.searchassist.com/landing.jsf?p=...

Since some of these redirects are temporary, Google apparently treats the whole chain as a temporary redirect, and so indexes the result under the original tinyurl.com URL.

Looking deeper in the Google results, I also found some links to URLs suspected by TinyURL of hosting harmful content. These links also go through a 302 redirect to a landing page at tinyurl.com/warning.php, and so get indexed at their original URL.

There are also other weird corner cases, such as TinyURL links redirecting back to another TinyURL. The common thread in all these cases seems to be that most if not all of them go through a temporary redirect at some point.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Ogunnowo487

Its' by design, when you have more (or heavy) link to page A, A will be shown at index

When you use a short URL, you goal is to "present" it, Google just did that you want.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Back to top | Use Dark Theme