: Wrong page is indexing for a specific keyword phrase on my site When you search for the keyword phrase "New Camaro Car," the page for "New Mustang Car" appears in the results instead of "New

When you search for the keyword phrase "New Camaro Car," the page for "New Mustang Car" appears in the results instead of "New Camaro Car."

Page #1 -
Page Title: New Camaro Car
URL: /new-camaro-car
H1: New Camaro Car
Page Content: Exact Phrase of "New Camaro Car" is used twice.
Search Result Ranking for "New Camaro Car" : not-indexing (for this search)

Page #2 -
Title: New Mustang Car
URL: /new-mustang-car
H1: New Mustang Car
Page Content: Exact Phrase is used twice for "New Mustang Car." But zero times for "New Camaro Car"
Search Result Ranking for "New Camaro Car": #1
Search Result Ranking for "New Mustang Car": #9

Why is my "New Mustang Car" page indexing for the "New Camaro Car" search instead of my "New Camaro Car" page?

The "New Camaro Car" page is indexed, and does appear on Google for different searches. There are no Google Penalties, and no duplicate content issues. When you do an exact quote search; "New Camaro Car," the "New Mustang Car" page is still appearing at #1 result, even though the phrase is not used once on the page. (It is the only webpage on Google that comes up without having the exact quote on the page). On Bing everything works and both are appearing in the top 5 for their desired keyword phrases.

Any ideas of why this could be happening?