Mobile app version of vmapp.org
Login or Join
Gail6891361

: Is there a better icon for Save All than multiple floppy disks? Visual Studio 2013 uses the 'Save to multiple floppy disks' icon from long ago to represent 'Save All' I am working on an application

@Gail6891361

Posted in: #Save

Visual Studio 2013 uses the 'Save to multiple floppy disks' icon from long ago to represent 'Save All'

I am working on an application where I need to represent 'Save All' with an understood icon. What is a better method for representing it without losing the understanding of the difference between save and save all?



Edit

The context of the save is as such -

There are widgets within a page that each have their own ability to progressively 'save' information. At the top of the page there is a 'Save everything' button that should save all of the changes in the whole page.

10.02% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Login to follow query

More posts by @Gail6891361

2 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

 

@Cooney243

Sometimes there is no substitute for words.

When you have an action with potential confusion words are hard to beat.

Icons exist for this purpose, as you mentioned. It's typically some multiple representation of the app's save icon. I think it usually falls short of the user's needs for clarity.

Ask yourself this: Will your audience stick around for the learning curve? If they're regular users, they may prefer a key sequence anyway. For the rest, words avoid confusion.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Turnbaugh909

The answer is yes, but... it depends on the experience of your users and anticipated users, the nature of the platform you're aiming at and the space and technologies you have to portray that icon."

And, further, this is an EVER evolving thing. So at no point in time is the answer going to be the same.

To all programmers having anything to do with this... the evolvement of the "zeitgeist of NOW" is something that's at the forefront of design. [all puns intended] If programmers cannot accept this inherent evolvement, the intuitive talents (magic) that make designing for the future an art form and the very nature of design and those attracted to it, then they should back off and leave the designers to chat amongst themselves.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Back to top | Use Dark Theme