Mobile app version of vmapp.org
Login or Join

Login to follow query

More posts by @Karen819

2 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

 

@BetL875

If you look at how it renders at dafont.com you'll see the same problem. It's not limited to Photoshop. It looks even worse in the OS font preview because, like many cheap fonts, it doesn't seem to have any hinting information at all.

You'll get a somewhat less obnoxious rendering if you use "Smooth" rather than "Crisp" for the anti-aliasing, but any typeface (or any shape, for that matter) with edges slanted at small angles is problematic for anti-aliasing at coarse resolutions. There are no exactly vertical or horizontal lines in this one; they're all sloped a few degrees.

You will always see this problem in Photoshop more than in Illustrator or InDesign, because Photoshop renders vectors and text at the document resolution, not the output device (screen, in this case) resolution that a vector-based application uses.

Follow Lèse's good advice and use a different (and better quality) font.

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


 

@Turnbaugh909

Photoshop doesn't AA text quite as well as most OS' native text rendering since it uses Photoshop's own AA algorithm, which doesn't make use of subpixel rendering (therefore it probably doesn't make use of ClearType hinting that's embedded in many fonts).

But even if it did, every implementation of AA has its limitations and detractors. Some people prefer the way Safari AAs, some people prefer IE. Some people prefer OS X's text rendering, some prefer Windows...

Rendering black on white without subpixel AA is especially difficult because there's so much contrast between the 2 colors that it'll either looked crisp but aliased, or AAed but blurry.

And then there's the fact that you're looking at your document at 200% magnification. So that's going to make the aliasing even more pronounced. Plus you're using a font that has very tight counters, so that's going to be problematic as well.

Your best bet is to try a different font that Photoshop plays nicer with and/or use a different foreground or background color. I personally avoid using AAed black text on white backgrounds in Photoshop most of the time for the same reason. If I need to use such a color scheme, then the text in Photoshop is usually just a placeholder for actually rendered text in a web layout that will be displayed with subpixel AA.


Edit:

Following "Happy New Year To All"'s link, and then following another duplicate link on that question lead to me this question. In the first answer by Stefan Monov, he provides a link to a Photoshop action that tries to simulate subpixel rendering, by a series of clever blending with 2 additional layers.

I've yet to try this action out, but it looks promising. However, you really need to weigh things carefully before using this because, even though it might make the text look better in 99% of cases, it could potentially cause it to look worse if:


the final image is printed
it is viewed on a rotated display (mobile or just a rotated monitor)
it is viewed on a display with non-standard subpixel order (some panels are ordered BGR instead of RGB)
it is viewed on a CRT display

10% popularity Vote Up Vote Down


Back to top | Use Dark Theme