: Are there any sites which provide feedback for logo designs? I know Behance, Dribbble etc allow designers to have feedback of their work too but their focus is mainly showcasing the work of

@Bryan765

Along with the previous answers, there is Desinion.

You can present two variations of your logo design along with a question and members can vote accordingly. An example question could be something like: "Which variation communicates _______ more effectively?"

Vote Up Vote Down

@Bryan765

If you criticize logos on here you'll just get a minus vote. Probably no one with good advice would bother because if you tell the truth people don't like it. So you will just get advice of whoever is left over who puts up with that.

So it comes down that asking the Internet what they think of your logo is like asking YouTube what they think of your video. Maybe someone knows what they're talking about, but odds are not and you'll just get a distraction.

You're the person who really cares about your logo, so learn to criticize it yourself. One good way is to use Google Images and look at the competition: pick the best ones and worst ones. Then list the things the good ones do right, and the things the bad ones are doing wrong. Then get really mean on your work and ask why you are doing the wrong things you criticized other logos for doing. Also get mean asking why you didn't do the things that are right you pointed out.

If you ask other people to help you with critique on your logo then you are really not any further than you started. Because now instead of having to be able to figure out if your logo is good or not you have to figure out if the criticism is good or not. It's kind of like you had one problem and you want to solve it by making another harder problem.

Vote Up Vote Down

@Connie430

Yes.

In addition to other suggestions already offered, don't forget...this site.

To zero in on logo critiques, search specifically for them.

Also, be sure to review guidelines for asking a great subjective question before posting a question to invite critiques – if you are not already familiar with them.

Vote Up Vote Down

@LarsenBagley460

Reddit can be a bit hit or miss with these things, but it's worth a shot:
www.reddit.com/r/design_critiques www.reddit.com/r/logo_critique www.reddit.com/r/logodesign

Vote Up Vote Down

@Martha945

Brands of the World has a critique section that does just this.


"Post your logo to receive comments and ratings in 4 different
subjects: Idea, Symbol, Typography and Colors. Mark useful comments as
helpful to reward commenters. Post new logo version and see how
ratings improve."

www.brandsoftheworld.com/critique

Vote Up Vote Down